Point of View - Masthead

Opinions will Be Verified. Facts Will Be Checked. Your Voice Will Be Heard.

Opinions will Be Verified.
Facts Will Be Checked.
Your Voice Will Be Heard.

Heath: The time is ripe for downtown Scottsdale’s rebirth

photo of downtown Scottsdale author
Larry Heath
By Larry Heath | Point of View

Downtown dies for two reasons.

They fail to replace functionally obsolete real estate with a modern, sales tax inducing streetscape, or they die from depopulation.

U-Haul’s heading out of Scottsdale is not our city’s problem, but our downtown is most certainly showing its age.

One area ripe for rebirth is across the canal from the iconic Scottsdale Waterfront building on the southwest corner of Camelback and Scottsdale roads. I say iconic, because that condominium midrise building is filled with wealthy owners who provide an economic windfall to area merchants and the city’s sales tax base.

The city seems to appreciate that midrise building, because they feature a picture of it on their website.

I remember when that corner used to be a vacant dirt lot, and Scottsdale Fashion Square was two detached, dying malls. Thankfully, a forward-thinking city council voted to fund a parking garage for Nordstroms.

That wise political decision (which included then council member David Ortega’s vote) resulted in the development of the Nordstroms wing of the mall, and the contiguous Waterfront project, including all the high rent restaurants around it.

(File Photos/DigitalFreePress)
Heath: The time is ripe for downtown Scottsdale’s rebirth

The logical path of progress for downtown Scottsdale is across the walking bridge over the canal to the somewhat dilapidated area on the south bank. However, the City Council has a vote before it (tomorrow) to reduce building heights in that area by 30 feet.

That’s enough to wreck development budgets given concrete and steel construction costs, and land costs which were based on current permitted height. It is also a “taking” of private property rights, and I suspect the owners of those properties agree.

I understand that the Goldwater Institute has already served notice that litigation might ensue.

Standing in the way of the metamorphosis of the south bank are a handful of property owners who are among Mayor Ortega’s biggest political donors. They were also the largest funders of an earlier protest that blocked development of a luxury project planned and approved for that area.

I cannot fathom why neighboring property owners would not be thrilled to have wealthy professionals and downsizing baby boomers residing across the street from their properties, but it seems politics-as-usual rather than what’s best for the city.

Another impediment to downtown Scottsdale following the gentrification path of every other urban city in America is a band of always grumpy Scottsdale NIMBYs. They want to keep things frumpy, with ranch style houses as far as the eye can see.

There’s an art to urban planning. Fighting it out zoning-case-by-zoning-case is not it. Proactive planning works far better.

Scottsdale’s five years away from build-out. Now’s the time to get things right.

Do we really want to hang our municipal hat on a downtown filled with a 1950s streetscape, or do we want to welcome sales tax inducing luxury properties?

Metro Phoenix is named after the mythological bird which was raised from ashes to rebirth. It’s time for Scottsdale to get on board with that rebirth mantra.

Editor’s note: Larry Heath is a resident of Scottsdale.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Category Sponsor

Do You Have a Point of View?

Arizona Digital Free Press - Icon

Point of View

Would you like to contribute to the Free Press Point of View?

If so, send your point of view to tfthornton@arizonadigitalfreepress.com. Editorial POLICY: Within 48 hours of receiving your submission the writing will either be published or denied with a formal explanation.

Published On:

Category Sponsor

Leon Law

Newsletter Sign Up

Scottsdale Daily Beat - Logo

Could we interest you in Local News That Matters? How about Enterprise Business Reporting & Real Property & Homes?

Caputi-336x280-01
Mountain Shadows 2
Kwasman Digital Free Press 1 copy
Cover_Spring-2024-SUSD-Showcase-magazine
Experience Scottsdale AD