Point of View - Masthead

Opinions will Be Verified. Facts Will Be Checked. Your Voice Will Be Heard.

Opinions will Be Verified.
Facts Will Be Checked.
Your Voice Will Be Heard.

Eskildson: a retort to SUSD’s ‘advantage’ in economic development

Loyd Eskildson
By Loyd Eskildson | Point of View

The Scottsdale Unified School District ‘advantage’ depicted in Dr. Menzel’s article is, in my opinion, mythical.

The study from Arizona State University cites from several serious flaws.

  1. Implying that because housing costs are on average 2.4 times more for homes located closer to a high-scoring public school than for homes located near a low-scoring public school, SUSD should be credited for the considerably more valuable homes in the SUSD district. That’s nonsense – the causation flows in the opposite direction. The fact that pupils from higher-income/better-educated parents score higher is probably the most agreed-upon relationship in education.
  2. Suggesting that ‘ … aggregate housing values rise by $19 to $20 for every dollar spent on state education’ is irrelevant because Arizona equalization funding is reduced for SUSD due to SUSD’s relatively higher assessed values.
  3. Brookings states that ‘there are around 30% fewer rental properties in the attendance zones around high performing schools (Rothwell, 2012),’ but cites no data for Scottsdale or the Town of Paradise Valley. However, it is well known that both Scottsdale and Paradise Valley have had major increases in rental properties and associated problems since that 2012 study was published.
  4. Ironically, the report cites ‘What You Make Depends on Where You Live: College Earnings Across States and Metropolitan Areas” by John Winters. That study emphasizes that graduates in in large cities and urban areas (Scottsdale/Phoenix) are more likely to earn more – hardly attributable to SUSD.

Finally, SUSD provides numerous obsolete high school courses instead of demanding material preparing graduates for success in an environment providing world-competitive, artificial Intelligence training.

Editor’s note: Mr. Eskildson is a resident of the Town of Paradise Valley and former chief deputy at the Maricopa County School Superintendent’s Office.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Category Sponsor

Do You Have a Point of View?

Arizona Digital Free Press - Icon

Point of View

Would you like to contribute to the Free Press Point of View?

If so, send your point of view to tfthornton@arizonadigitalfreepress.com. Editorial POLICY: Within 48 hours of receiving your submission the writing will either be published or denied with a formal explanation.

Category Sponsor

Leon Law

Newsletter Sign Up

Scottsdale Daily Beat - Logo

Could we interest you in Local News That Matters? How about Enterprise Business Reporting & Free Press Philanthropy?

Mountain Shadows 2
Honor Health
Lisa Borowsky - Ad


Paradise Valley